Final 5 Performance: spoiler/discussion thread

[EmoJoe]

For tonight :D

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Whats the theme?!

[EmoJoe]

According to IDF its Top 40 songs from 2004..or something like that. Didnt they just have a 2000 theme?!?!?!

[EmoJoe]

From IDF:

The themes for tonight are:

Top 40
50's and 60's

Ryan was on my local radio station this morning!!!!

Wow thats dumb..two themes? I guess since their doing two songs, but why 60s again?

[Cactus Jack]

50s and 60s AWESOME!!!!!


Top 40 2004?

I hoope Scott does Milkshake so he can do a horrible song

[David]

From IDF:



Wow thats dumb..two themes? I guess since their doing two songs, but why 60s again?

I know =/

[EmoJoe]

It would be much better if it was just 50s.

[JT]

I'm still waiting for a Carpenters theme...but maybe it would be best if there wasn't one. I don't want Scott ruining one of their songs, you know, like Clay and Ruben did...

[Brian]

I hoope Scott does Milkshake so he can do a horrible song



:lol: :lol: :lol:

[Cactus Jack]

:lol: :lol: :lol:
:D :D :D

[David]

it's starting :D :D

[EmoJoe]

They're announcing the theme

2 themes...Lebran and Stoller and this weeks billboard hits or something

[David]

1. Anthony Fedorov - Poison Ivy (1959)

He has his glasses. He's wearing a red shirt, starting off from the platform. It's an okay performance, very karaoke.

Randy - Very out of tune in the beginning, came back at the end, wasn't a winning performance
Paula - Showed versatility
Simon - you're lucky you're singing 2 songs, it was incredibly amateurish.

His 2nd performance is a ballad, according to Paula.

[David]

They're announcing the theme

2 themes...Lebran and Stoller and this weeks billboard hits or something
Yup. Songs from this week's Billboard Top 40 or something.

Hm. Very limited.

[David]

http://www.billboard.com/bb/charts/hot100.jsp

[Cactus Jack]

LEIBER AND STOLLER! Not Lebran and Stoller LOL sorry its just that well I LOVE the 50s so... LOL


Anthony : Wasnt his best, but I love that song, and Im a Coasters fan so.. I kinda liked itLOL

[Pus$y Galore]

O.k. - first of all - LOVE Snotty's real cool hat tonight!!! WTF was that all about!!!! :lol:

And I'm sorry, but I have to agree with Simon on Anthony's Poison Ivy - that was pretty bad (and he's been soooo good the last three weeks).

Really out of tune at the beginning and just not his type of song I think. Hopefully his ballad will be better. A lot better.


I'm praying Scott will stumble on the steps, fall, knock out a few teeth and he can't sing. Just give us all a break!

[EmoJoe]

I thought Scott was horrible. Thats just me

My rankings

FIRST PERFOMANCES:

Anthony- 7.5/10
Scott- 2/10

[David]

2. Scott Savol - On Broadway

Let me just say, I looooove this song. haha. Um, he starts off really fun and good, but the song is just all on the same level the whole time. It was good for him though.

Randy - Definitely some bad notes, but every week you seem to come up with enough of the right vocals to pull it out.
Paula - "Mocksy"?? I have no idea what she said.
Simon - You've had more escapes than Hudini. There were some bad notes, but it was probably your best performance.

[Pus$y Galore]

I was with Randy (I HATE to admit it). Few bum notes, but not bad as long as you don't look at him. To me, it was TOO distracting him singing it to Simon.

This better not mean that Anthony will pay for it this week tho. :mad:

[Pus$y Galore]

Vonzelle did well even though I've never heard that song before and don't particularly want to hear it again!! ;)

[David]

3. Vonzell Solomon - Treat Me Nice (Elvis Presley)

She looks great. It's an upbeat song. She's doing a GREAT job. She does well with the high notes, and it's definitely one of her better performances.

Randy - That was one of the best vocals, I don't even know that song, but it was incredible. That's how to win this.
Paula - Great vocals
Simon - There were elements of that performance that were very good, but it was kind of a mess; childish, cute.

[EmoJoe]

Vonzell's up, singing Treat Me Nice by Elvis

Shes pretty good, but at some parts (mostly in the beginning) shes singing under the band like Carrie did last week so in some parts, you can barely understand what shes saying. But overall its good: 8.5/10. Best so far.

Randy: That was one of the best vocals out of a song i've ever heard. I barely know that song and you made me like it. Incredible performance
Paula: Any musical person out there would get you in a minute to put you on Brodway (or something like that)
Simon: Some elements were good, but it was a bit of a mess. It was a little childish and cute. It was a mess

I dont really agree with Simon. But oh well

[EmoJoe]

RANKINGS

First Perfomances:

Vonzell- 8.5/10
Anthony- 7.5/10
Scott- 2/10

I think Carrie is last :woohoo:

[David]

BO AND CARRIE AFTER THE BREAK!!

Ryan said Bo's name first, so I HOPE that means that Carrie is performing last. They had a shot of them before the break, and Carrie looks fantabulous!! Her hair is straight yet again :D

[EmoJoe]

O.k. - first of all - LOVE Snotty's real cool hat tonight!!! WTF was that all about!!!! :lol:

And I'm sorry, but I have to agree with Simon on Anthony's Poison Ivy - that was pretty bad (and he's been soooo good the last three weeks).

Really out of tune at the beginning and just not his type of song I think. Hopefully his ballad will be better. A lot better.


I'm praying Scott will stumble on the steps, fall, knock out a few teeth and he can't sing. Just give us all a break!
Seriously- if he is safe this week than there is something really wrong. Its Vote for the Worst doing it though.

[EmoJoe]

BO AND CARRIE AFTER THE BREAK!!

Ryan said Bo's name first, so I HOPE that means that Carrie is performing last. They had a shot of them before the break, and Carrie looks fantabulous!! Her hair is straight yet again :DCarrie waved to the crowd too :D Aww shes so adorbale

[David]

hmm "When You Tell Me That You Love Me", "Truth Is", "Behind These Hazel Eyes", "Since U Been Gone", and "Breakaway" are all in the top 50 this week.

[Cactus Jack]

Scott : I love this song, I thought it was pretty good but much better than last week



VOnzell : AWESOME!!!

[EmoJoe]

hmm "When You Tell Me That You Love Me", "Truth Is", "Behind These Hazel Eyes", "Since U Been Gone", and "Breakaway" are all in the top 50 this week.
:woohoo: CARRIE WOULD SOUND GREAT WITH BREAKAWAY!!!!!

I doubt any will do When You Tell Me That You Love Me though, being it was on the single.

[EmoJoe]

Bo is up- which means CARRIE IS LAST

Bo is doing Stand By Me by some guy, i didnt catch the name

I'll just post my opinions being David is covering the judges comments :lol:

Bo- its kinda slow for him, its pretty good, not his best yet, its kinda boring for him. Its not horrible but its not his best. 8/10 for him, just a bit behind Vonzell.

Rankings for 1st performance:

Vonzell: 8.5/10
Bo: 8/10
Anthony: 7.5/10
Scott: i'll raise his to a 5/10

[Pus$y Galore]

Not bad for Bo - he's pretty consistent. Not the greatest version of it ever (and I LOVE Stand By Me), but still respectable.

[David]

CARRIE IS GOING LAST :D :D

4. Bo Bice - Stand By Me

I love this song too!! Okay, Bo is doing another good job. He commands the audience really well, and his vocals are for the most part, spot on. The last note was really good too.

Randy - You picked the right song, know who you are, what record you should make. You are definitely on your way, it was great dude.
Paula - It's great when you pick a song that everyone knows. You colored it all up with Bo. There's no need to critique you.
Simon - You chose the best song by a mile.

[Pus$y Galore]

Carrie - fabulous performance! I like it better than Elvis' version!!!! :D :wave:

To me, her best performance yet! She rocked the house in Constantine's absence!!

[EmoJoe]

Carrie is up, aww i hope she does good :)

Shes doing Trouble by Elvis. Hope she pulls it off

Shes REALLY good. Awesome. One of her best!!! Nothing tops Alone, but this comes close! ;) I'll give her a 10/10 :D Best of the night so far

Judges love it

My rankings for 1st perfomances:

Carrie-10/10
Vonzell- 8.5/10
Bo- 8/10
Anthony- 7.5/10
Scott- 5/10

Not a bad night tonight so far.

2nd performences are coming up.

CARRIE RULES THIS SHOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[David]

5. Carrie Underwood - Trouble - Elvis Presley

In her film clip, she did a little Elvis grin. Awww.

BUT.

WOW. She's doing a GREAT job. She has amazing stage presence. She kicks the microphone stand to the audience. It's AMAZING. Atleast in my opinion. Carrie fans will definitely be pleased!

Randy - Same thing to Bo, you know who you are, great song choice, and you SANG it
Paula - It was so much fun, my favorite performance from you
Simon - Absolutely agree with Randy. The whole point is to give your fans what they wanted.

AAAAAAAHH I <3 CARRIE!!!

[David]

Carrie - fabulous performance! I like it better than Elvis' version!!!! :D :wave:

To me, her best performance yet! She rocked the house in Constantine's absence!!
I was so amazed, because she really showed her personality, and it was awesome to see that.

[EmoJoe]

Carrie now officaly RULES this season

[EmoJoe]

I was so amazed, because she really showed her personality, and it was awesome to see that.
Yeah, she finally got stage presence AND vocals down in 1 perfomance. Thats why she rules this show now.

[Pus$y Galore]

I was so amazed, because she really showed her personality, and it was awesome to see that.


Yup - she REALLY did tonight! She even knows how to style her hair to go with the song have you noticed that?

She should be the next Idol - she does deserve it.

[EmoJoe]

Anthony is singing...i have no idea. But hopefully i reconize it.

The beginning is VERY rough. It gets better, but the beginning is VERY rough. And i still dont reconzize the song. But seriously, i like this one a lot better than his first one. 8/10 for this one.

Second performance ratings:

Anthony- 8/10

[Pus$y Galore]

Anthony on the ballad......eeehhh

He may be in trouble tomorrow folks. With this stupid trend of keeping Snott in, Anthony could have left too many holes in both performances.

I'm shocked at Simon's take!!!! :eek:

[David]

1. Anthony Fedorov - Incomplete (BSB!!)

They're changing clothes!! He ditched the glasses. He's doing a good job. I really like him doing ballads. Very good IMO, even though the judges seem to disagree.

Randy - Some pitch problems, it was okay, but it was 5/10 compared to BSB.
Paula - It's difficult to do a song performed by a group, but I think you did a good job overall.
Simon - Disastrous start, but you absolutely chose the right song and did it really well.

[EmoJoe]

Scott is up. I have my remote ready and my finger on the mure button so i can mute it if its REALLY bad

Oh man i hate to say it, but its not bad. Sadly. I still hate him though. Uggh...6/10 I guess *sighs*

Man, Anthony is in trouble.

Scott has a bad attitude. Hes giving Simon dirty looks and saying "im not going home". At least everyone else accepts critsism.

[Pus$y Galore]

AHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Did you hear Scott about getting someone to do his wardrobe and that to make him more appealing?!! The only thing on him that would make him more appealing to me is a 600 lb. cement brick!!! :rolleyes:

Don't like this song much. I wish he'd stop that "hand slap" spastic thing.

Give me a break on the kiss blows!

I guess a 7/10

[David]

2. Scott Savol - some r/b song, i think it's "everytime you go away", not anthony's song 3 weeks ago :lol: (Brian McKnight)

"i don't give a damn with what my homies say" :lol:. Ugh, it's okay. Goodish. Not amazing.

Randy - Did it again, you pulled it out. Congrats.
Paula - Best night of the whole competition.
Simon - More flat than you were in tune.

LMAO Scott goes "i'm not going home" before Simon even talks.

[EmoJoe]

I hope our plan works (the voting crazy for other contestants plan) I WANT SCOTT GONE

[EmoJoe]

Where are Jeff and Mackenzie? We have no one to spoil this too :p

[eltonfan80]

i agree too i hope scott leave tommrow that would make my day

[David]

Scott is up. I have my remote ready and my finger on the mure button so i can mute it if its REALLY bad

Oh man i hate to say it, but its not bad. Sadly. I still hate him though. Uggh...6/10 I guess *sighs*

Man, Anthony is in trouble.

Scott has a bad attitude. Hes giving Simon dirty looks and saying "im not going home". At least everyone else accepts critsism.

Yeah, seriously. I hate it when he does that.

But uhm, yeah, Anthony's in a bit of trouble. However, keep in mind, it is his birthday tomorrow :lol: And I know that we shouldn't vote for them just because it's their birthday, but there's a boost of inspiration for y`all. And on top of that, he's probably gonna be in the bottom of the bunch, with Scott, so let's make him edge him out.

[EmoJoe]

Yeah, seriously. I hate it when he does that.

But uhm, yeah, Anthony's in a bit of trouble. However, keep in mind, it is his birthday tomorrow :lol: And I know that we shouldn't vote for them just because it's their birthday, but there's a boost of inspiration for y`all. And on top of that, he's probably gonna be in the bottom of the bunch, with Scott, so let's make him edge him out.
I might give a vote or 2 to Anthony because i dont want him to go on his birthday. But majority of my votes are going to Carrie ;)

[David]

Where are Jeff and Mackenzie? We have no one to spoil this too :p

Oh well. We'll pretend that they're reading.

[James"Thunder"Early]

Where are Jeff and Mackenzie? We have no one to spoil this too :pI'm here reading how all the singers are doing.

[Cactus Jack]

BO AND CARRIE ROCKED!

Anthony - He was great!

Scott-- Ehhish but I still liked him a bit

[EmoJoe]

Vonzell is singing When You Tell Me That You Love Me..im shocked. Shes doing a good job, but i cant believe she picked that. 9/10 for her..shes doing an awesome job at this.

2nd perfomance rankings:

Vonzell: 9/10
Anthony: 7.7/10
Scott: 6/10

[Pus$y Galore]

Wasn't my favorite song, but she did do a good job. Don't know where Simon was with those comments.

[David]

3. I knew it. Vonzell's doing "When You Tell Me That You Love Me".

Vonzell looks beautiful again. She has a really nice brown dress. The beginning is really nice. The middle and end are even better. Hate to say it, but I prefer this over the album cut.

[STANDING O'S FROM RANDY AND PAULA]
Randy - Perfect vocal.
Paula - Really good, blah blah.
Simon - I think you're very vulnerable tonight, because it wasn't a perfect vocal.

What's up with Simon!? This is like what happened to Carmen and Jasmine. He just decides to hate them.

[EmoJoe]

Bo is up, and he is pretty good, but again, its too boring for Bo. But hes good overall, the vocals are great as usual, 9/10, tied with Vonzell.

2nd perfomance rankings:

Vonzell and Bo: 9/10
Anthony: 7.7/10
Scott: 6.6/10

Word of the night for Simon tonight is "amuture". He said Anthony sounded like an amuture and he said Bo makes some contestants look like amutures.

[David]

4. Bo Bice - that Los Lonely Boys song, i think it's called "Heaven"

He's doing another great job.

Oh hey, JPL is in the audience! lol. Um, it was a good performance. That's all I can say, because he's really consistent. And lookey there, more standing ovations from Randy and Paula.

Randy - You're the captain of the dawg pound.
Paula - Fantastic.
Simon - You've had a good night tonight. You're making some of the other singers look like amateurs.

[David]

Man, Carrie has a LOT of signs in the audience.

[EmoJoe]

Man, Carrie has a LOT of signs in the audience.
Cause she has a HUGE fanbase

I hope Carrie does an AWESOME job. I think she will though :D

[EmoJoe]

CMON i wanna hear Carrie. GO AWAY COMMERICALS

[Cactus Jack]

Vonzell : :eek: Didnt think shed pick that! But it was awesome!


Bo : Awesome! Loved it!

[EmoJoe]

Carries up :D

Vocals are great...shes very good. Not as exciting as her first perfomance, but its still good. 10/10 AGAIN for Carrie

Complete 2nd perfomance rankings:

Carrie: 10/10
Bo and Vonzell: 9/10
Anthony: 7.7/10
Scott: 6.6/10

:D

[David]

5. Carrie Underwood - some country song.

She starts off sitting down. Her dress is beautiful. She sounds amazing. It wasn't a power ballad, its more subdued, but it was perfect for her. I was actually touched.

Randy - Another great, perfect vocal performance.
Paula - First I thought "safe song", but then I hear you sing. It was eloquent, beautiful, perfect.
Simon - Very good; other than it was a little robotic, it was beautiful.

[Miss Golden]

My Final 5 rankings from tonight:

1. Bo
2. Carrie
3. Vonzell
4. Scott
5. Anthony

Bottom 3 Predictions:

Vonzell
Scott
Anthony - OUT

There is no way Bo or Carrie should be in the Final 3. Judging by the performances tonight, Anthony should leave, actually Scott was better than Anthony, but any of those 3 that I have in the bottom could leave as Bo and Carrie have established themselves as better than the rest.

[EmoJoe]

I cant get through ONCE for Carrie

[Cactus Jack]

CARRIE WAS AWESOME!

[David]

I'm rewatching it now, and I must add that Paula said "you're a star" at the end of her comment to her first performance :woohoo:

So I guess it's official, Carrie and Bo are in the finale.

[EmoJoe]

My bottom 3 predictions:

Vonzell (safe first)
Anthony
Scott

Either Anthony or Scott can go.

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

Umm how was Vonzell's second song choice fair at all? That was crap.

And I can't get through at all for Bo. I'm getting dead air and an operator saying my call cannot be completed..

[EmoJoe]

I got like 2 in for Carrie. Ugggh

[David]

I cant get through ONCE for Carrie

I got through once for her.

I'm voting for her mostly, and I'll give some to Anthony and Vonzell, because I'm gonna be mad if they're the bottom 2.

[EmoJoe]

I got through once for her.

I'm voting for her mostly, and I'll give some to Anthony and Vonzell, because I'm gonna be mad if they're the bottom 2.
Everyones line is busy. Well i didnt check Scotts.

[David]

My bottom 3 predictions:

Vonzell (safe first)
Anthony
Scott

Either Anthony or Scott can go.

It'll only be the bottom 2, so I'm assuming it'll be Scott and Vonzell, with Vonzell leaving. Just my luck.

Yeah Anthony deserves to be in the bottom 2, but there are a lot of factors to keep in mind. He was in the bottom 2 last week, it's his birthday tomorrow, he sang a Backstreet Boys song, and the judges were mean to him. So I won't be surprised if he's safe.

VONZELL BETTER NOT LEAVE TOMORROW THOUGH.

[David]

Everyones line is busy. Well i didnt check Scotts.

Yeah, don't :lol:

[Janet McFarland]

Scott: Want him to go home
Anthony: Thought both performances sucked actually
Bo: I thought he did the best
Vonzell: I love her! I thought she did great on both performances
Carrie: I liked the first one better. I just wish she had an "Alone" type of performance, something that will blow me away

[EmoJoe]

Carrie: I liked the first one better. I just wish she had an "Alone" type of performance, something that will blow me away
Alone is still my fav of hers, but her perfomances this week blew me away

[Krisalicious]

First of all.. OMG DID ANYONE ELSE SEE JPL?! - dies -

Anyway...

Anthony: His first song was pretty good... good to see him having fun, plus I kinda missed his glasses. I LOVED his second song though. LOOOOOOOVED! I love Incomplete so much...sure he's no Backstreet Boy (and that's a good thing -.-) but he did it great and I'm glad Simon thought so too.

Scott: Okay...umm... his first performance was actually good I thought -______- maybe umm even his best ever OKAY *SLAPS SELF AND REMEMBERS SHE'S PRESIDENT OF HIS ANTI CLUB* but god.. he was so ****ing conceited tonight it was disgusting. Meh meh meh look at me I'm gonna sing On Broadway cuz I'm a star ooh what now Simon I'm big and bad and out of controlllll!!!!!!!! yeah okay :rolleyes: so I hope others notice how much of an ******* this guy is and they DON'T PICK UP THE PHONE AND VOTE FOR HIM!!! Oh yeah, and I thought his second performance sucked :).
DO. NOT. VOTE. FOR. SCOTT!!!!!!!

Vonzell: Well with my Constantine gone - sigh - she's my new favorite. Both of her performances were amazing. I LOVE her personality... she's cute but not like annoyingly cute... and I think she's the best singer left in the competition. I don't know which song I liked more. I think I prefer her version of When You Tell Me That You Love Me over all the idols singing it together. I'm voting for her immense amounts tonight. IMO she was the best tonight. Simon is crazy... he thinks Vonzell had an off night? ****, I wonder what he considers an off night for Scott then. :rolleyes:

Bo: HE WAS AWESOME TONIGHT. Oh man, both songs were perfect for him and I loved both of them. I think he's my second favorite now. And what I love about him is that he knows he's good but he doesn't go flaunting it like a certain marshmallow out there (who, by the way, isn't even great but he thinks he is) and aaahhh. I'm voting for Bo too.

Carrie: When she first started singing her first song and it was all slow I was like ................ :confused: :eek: but then as it got faster I was like oh, that's Carrie. The second song kind of bored me, but she sang it really well.

Now... everyone... VOTE... for ANYONE BUT SCOTT!!!!!

[Cactus Jack]

Alone is still my fav of hers, but her perfomances this week blew me away
Ditto

[EmoJoe]

Alright im not gonna try voting again til 9:30 cause i cant get through

[EmoJoe]

I can get through now

[*InThisMoment*]

Scott - First performance was ok, but I still want him booted. Second was forgettable and boring.
Anthony - First was horrendous. Second was awesome. Really really liked it.
Vonzell - First performance was too.. sharp. Not very good at all IMO. Second was really good. I enjoyed it.
Bo - Both of his performances were very good.
Carrie - First was good, second was boring. Still think she's VERY overrated and generic.

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

First of all.. OMG DID ANYONE ELSE SEE JPL?! - dies -

JPL?!?!?!?!? NO! WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT?!

OMG I love him.

[Krisalicious]

JPL?!?!?!?!? NO! WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT?!

OMG I love him.

I'm pretty sure that was him! They showed him for only like a second though. Aww I like his new shorter hair.

[David]

I'm pretty sure that was him! They showed him for only like a second though. Aww I like his new shorter hair.
Yeah, I saw him too.

[David]

5 votes for Carrie and Vonzell so far.

[Krisalicious]

Uhh I don't exactly know where to post this, so I guess I'll just say it here :lol: during the commercials, CONSTANTINE came on and I screamed. He's going to be on my local news in 15 minutes...I live close to NYC so we get all the NYC stations. Anyway, he said something like "I'll tell YOU what Simon told me backstage last week." And I was just like :eek:!! This should be VERY interesting. I'll let you all know what he says.

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

Uhh I don't exactly know where to post this, so I guess I'll just say it here :lol: during the commercials, CONSTANTINE came on and I screamed. He's going to be on my local news in 15 minutes...I live close to NYC so we get all the NYC stations. Anyway, he said something like "I'll tell YOU what Simon told me backstage last week." And I was just like :eek:!! This should be VERY interesting. I'll let you all know what he says.
*molests* Did you see him on E! News Live today? Ohhh man. I LOVE YOU.

[Krisalicious]

*molests* Did you see him on E! News Live today? Ohhh man. I LOVE YOU.

Ah no I didn't...what did he say?

[Janet McFarland]

Uhh I don't exactly know where to post this, so I guess I'll just say it here :lol: during the commercials, CONSTANTINE came on and I screamed. He's going to be on my local news in 15 minutes...I live close to NYC so we get all the NYC stations. Anyway, he said something like "I'll tell YOU what Simon told me backstage last week." And I was just like :eek:!! This should be VERY interesting. I'll let you all know what he says.

Yeah I saw that :lol: He's so sexy.

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

Ah no I didn't...what did he say?
He said he doesn't like to party ("Not to disappoint anyone...") and that he never made women go crazy before because he used to be a dork until he grew his hair. They were standing on a street corner and he looks up and hes like "Hey, there's a Pray For the Soul of Betty sticker on this stoplight!" And he was talking about pizza places and stuff. Ohhh he's just so cute.

[vienna waits]

I. LOVE. CARRIE.

[vienna waits]

Where are Jeff and Mackenzie? We have no one to spoil this too :p
yeah i didn't let myself get online.. i was a nervous wreck the whole show lol

[Krisalicious]

He said he doesn't like to party ("Not to disappoint anyone...") and that he never made women go crazy before because he used to be a dork until he grew his hair. They were standing on a street corner and he looks up and hes like "Hey, there's a Pray For the Soul of Betty sticker on this stoplight!" And he was talking about pizza places and stuff. Ohhh he's just so cute.

:lol: Awww I love him. I'm watching the news now but he hasn't come on yet.

[vienna waits]

JPL?!?!?!?!? NO! WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT?!

OMG I love him.
wooo that looks familiar. YEAH i saw him i was like "mom! we just saw him the other day." it looked like he was wearing the same jacket.

[David]

I'm rewatching it, and man, Carrie's 2nd performance was soooo nice. Yeah, it wasn't a powerful song or whatever, but she proved that she can still do an awesome job with a "nice song".

[Krisalicious]

Alright.. Constantine said that he and Bo "rocked out" together off the show and that the night he got voted off, Simon took him aside and said "I just want to thank you for bringing something awesome to the show" ... haha, awesome? lol he probably said something else but Constantine changed it because...I honestly can't picture Simon saying "awesome". But I'm glad he's happy :)

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

JPL!!!!!!!! *flails* I had to work 4-8 so I missed the first half :grr: [VCRS = <333] and I asked my parents if anyone good was in the audience. My Dad said no. Then I saw JPL and yelled at him.

Anthony <3333 I havent seen his first song yet, but from the recap it looked kinda bad. WHY ANTHONY WHY.

[-*Forever*-]

My ranking.

1. Carrie
2. Bo
3. Vonzell
4. Scott/Anthony

[G-Force Glockstar]

My ranking.

1. Carrie
2. Bo
3. Vonzell
4. Scott/Anthony

Same here except number 4 for my ranking is Anthony and Scott is number 5.

And OMG Carrie did so awesome!!! Especially on her first song (the Elvis one)!!!! :)

My votes:

Vonzell: 50
Carrie: 102

My Dad made me stop voting a little before 10:30 :cuss:
Isn't he mean to do that???!!!!!

[JT]

Is it just me...or was that Charlie's Angels's Cheryl Ladd in the audience when Scott went on his arrogant, annoying, conceited "I'm not going home" tirade?!

[James"Thunder"Early]

Is it just me...or was that Charlie's Angels's Cheryl Ladd in the audience when Scott went on his arrogant, annoying, conceited "I'm not going home" tirade?!That was her.

[Zebra 3]

I'm sorry I didn't notice Cheryl Ladd.