Fantasia Barrino or Diana DeGarmo

[David]

Which do you like better?

[~Tropical Punch 19~]

Diana!

[danellemarie3]

Diana!!!!!!!!

[HuntingtonM15]

Diana

[Cactus Jack]

Diana!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1


Fantasia's cool, but I wnat Queen DeGarmo to win!

[David]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Which do you like better? i forgot to mention who i wanted...

Diana!

[Krisalicious]

hmm....*PONDERS*









































DIANA DEGARMO!!!!!!!


*prepares fingers for the massive dialing of 1-866-436-5701 tonight*

[*InThisMoment*]

I like Tasia better. :D

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

duuuh..Fantasia's better :D

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

DIANA!!!!

[G-Force Glockstar]

I want Diana to win, but I bet Fantasia will win.
But both of them would make a PERFECT American Idol! :)

[Faith]

Diana

[Vegas Girl]

Diana shouted the first song, was good on the second, and was off key on the last one.

FANTASIA

[gOoSe]

fantasia shouted all her songs..seriously

[Natalle]

Diana voice is slightly hoarse from this contest, same as Kelly Clarkson the first year. She had a bit of problem with some notes but I'm sure it's from exhausted vocal chords and for giving 500% every week.

I can't believe Randy and Paula couldn't tell the difference since for the entire run of AI Diana has been flawless.

Dianas song choices show she really wants to win.

I can't believe how rude Simon was to her. How can he sleep at night. So disrespectful to this amazing girl who is still in high school and always kind.

GO DIANA! YOU ARE THE AMERICAN IDOL!!!

[db108108]

Diana's good, in fact great, but Fantasia is phenominal. Her last performance tonight was a sheer knock out and will win her the competition. she did butcher the first one though, but that kind of song is not playing into her talents. Diana is more "put the words in front of me and I'll belt them out," while Fantasia fully interprets her music and takes us for the ride.

[Burley_Furley]

Fantasia

[-*Leah*-]

FANTASIA!!!


She is the best, no doubt. :D

[Vegas Girl]

I agree. Fantasia interprets the song and gets very emotional.
Diana looks like she's just going through the motions.

If Diana's head gets any bigger, it will be a pumpkin!

[automatic princess]

Diana DeGarmo

[-*Forever*-]

I definately think Diana. Diana has only hit one bad note in the competition, she shouldn't get criticized for ONE BAD NOTE when John Stevens got through on a whole crapload of bad notes.

Don't get me wrong, Fantasia is great. But her screaming, "yeah yeah yeah"'s, and... yeah, Diana should win.

[Vegas Girl]

Why do so many of your care THAAAAT much if Diana wins? It's not like she's your sister. :rolleyes:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
Why do so many of your care THAAAAT much if Diana wins? It's not like she's your sister. :rolleyes: Because we're fans of her. Why did some people want John Peter Lewis or Amy Adams to win?


Part of me hopes Diana loses (:eek: ) just so when her album comes out, it sells way more than Fantasia's. But, in all honesty, I dont think this years competition is as close and not as popular, so if she does come in 2nd it wouldnt make as big of an impact as last year. So with that, I hope she wins.:D

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
I agree. Fantasia interprets the song and gets very emotional.
Diana looks like she's just going through the motions.

I agree, you can really feel when Fantasia sings, while Diana does almost nothing to differentiate herself from 100's of other singers...the only time she sounds good is when she belts..she cant sing a song without shouting a note for 10 seconds.

[Janet McFarland]

DIANA DEGARMO ALL THE WAY BABY! SHE ROCKS!
I agree with whoever said Fantasia screams when she sings , b/c she does , especially last night! But I'm definitely rooting for Diana!!!! She has a beautiful voice and just by looking at her , SHE'S A STAR! :D
:wave:

[HuntingtonM15]

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Don't get me wrong, Fantasia is great. But her screaming, "yeah yeah yeah"'s, and... yeah, Diana should win.

I agree. It is SO friggen annoying how she always ends songs like that!

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by HuntingtonM15
I agree. It is SO friggen annoying how she always ends songs like that! :nod: She can sing Ill admit.. she doesnt have to add all those yeahs.

[Janet McFarland]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
:nod: She can sing Ill admit.. she doesnt have to add all those yeahs.

I always thought that was part of the song .. shows what I know :rolleyes: