Can't believe Jasmine survives. Shock of the night

[TVFactFan]

The horrible singing 17 year old somehow escapes elimination and moves on. I'm truly stunned.

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

well, she'll get bashed on all the entertainment shows, that's for sure. I cant believe Fantasia and LaToya were in the bottom 2...it's just really wrong to me, and...well nevermind. Jasmine will definitely be out next week, tho.

[Lady T]

Originally posted by TVShow Analyzer
The horrible singing 17 year old somehow escapes elimination and moves on. I'm truly stunned. I love Jasmine, no, she is far from being the best singer on American idol, but watching her last night, and breaking down and crying, it just touched me so, that I voted for her 3 times...

[Vegas Girl]

She knew she deserved to go, and the audience let her know too.
Are people tone deaf? Or are kids just voting for her hundreds of times because she's closer to their age? LaToya has the better voice!

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

but remember, Jasmine was crying...so that made ppl feel so sorry for her...and plus LaToya lacks that certain personality!

[Lady T]

Originally posted by Undercover Angel
I love Jasmine, no, she is far from being the best singer on American idol, but watching her last night, and breaking down and crying, it just touched me so, that I voted for her 3 times...

[Brian]

I think Latoya is still going to get a record deal. I think she is one of the best singers in the last two seasons (I didn't watch season one) and I'm not exagerrating.

I'm still disgusted, though. Jasmine should have been in the bottom two and apparently her tears got her more sympathy votes. I'm a big fan of her but I think she should go next week. If any of the other two are eliminated before she is it'll be a joke.

[Vegas Girl]

What if everyone cried? Then who do you vote for? She shouldn't win based on sympathy!

[-*Forever*-]

I can't even comment properly on this. I'm too excited.

*FIRECRACKERS AND HOES*

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

Paula looked upset...they showed her for like 1/2 second, and she had her back turned and was like, really crying, and Randy had his arm around her...

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
What if everyone cried? Then who do you vote for? She shouldn't win based on sympathy! exactly....anyway you're going to have to be a lot thicker skinned than that if u really want to survive in the music business...

[David]

coming from a Jasmine fan. Jasmine should have gone home tonight, without a doubt.

But ahhhhh when it came between Fantasia and LaToya, i wanted LATOYA TO BE SAFE!!!! She was supposed to win this thing. Aaah. Nooooooooo. Well, atleast ppl cant blame me, because i didnt vote for jasmine last night, because i didnt want to put her through another week... my votes were mainly too Diana, and i also gave a few to laToya... none to Fantasia though.

aaah LaToya has the best voice, and she wouldve given the American Idol title more credibility.. however the thing that went against her was that her first performance which was just okay, and again, the lack of personality. She has improved her personality, but I agree with what Simon said last night to LaToya.. we know nothing else about her..

but on the bright side, LaToya will definitely get a record contract, and she will be AWESOME in the future.

[Christmas Snow]

I think Jasmine should not even bother singing and sit on the stage and cry the whole time, that'll get her more votes than her singing.

[Lady T]

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
What if everyone cried? Then who do you vote for? She shouldn't win based on sympathy! Well, unfortunately she did gain a lot on unnecessary votes due to the fact that she broke down and cried, she touched me, but personally, I think that La Toya London is the best singer...

[Lady T]

Originally posted by °Bubbly Blonde°
exactly....anyway you're going to have to be a lot thicker skinned than that if u really want to survive in the music business... ..or life in general...:(

[David]

Originally posted by Undercover Angel
Well, unfortunately she did gain a lot on unnecessary votes due to the fact that she broke down and cried, she touched me, but personally, I think that La Toya London is the best singer... i think it just comes to show that the judges should not to be so hurtful to contestants, and say "you're definitely gonna go" and "u better hope ur hometown votes for you" because its just gonna make America vote 10x harder ... for some reason the "absolutely dreadful" comment doesnt hurt the voting any.

im still a jasmine fan, but i am no longer voting for her.

[TVFactFan]

That crying bothered me. I was like "grow the hell up"

[Lady T]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
i think it just comes to show that the judges should not to be so hurtful to contestants, and say "you're definitely gonna go" and "u better hope ur hometown votes for you" because its just gonna make America vote 10x harder ... for some reason the "absolutely dreadful" comment doesnt hurt the voting any.

im still a jasmine fan, but i am no longer voting for her. Harsh judgment is what made Simon so imfamous..

[David]

Originally posted by TVShow Analyzer
That crying bothered me. I was like "grow the hell up" well i mean.. if Ryan didnt ask her "was it hard singing that song", they couldve hurried to the commercial break, and she couldve ran backstage.. but Ryan and the cameraman had to make it too darn obvious

[Lady T]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
well i mean.. if Ryan didnt ask her "was it hard singing that song", they couldve hurried to the commercial break, and she couldve ran backstage.. but Ryan and the cameraman had to make it too darn obvious But in a way, even allowing Jasmine to be seen crying is callous, but it did help her gain, extra votes...

[*InThisMoment*]

Well, was this really SO suprising? The girl was up on stage bawling. er. I'm not really a fan of La Toya, but she was the best on the show. She's gonna be fine without AI. I think La Toya's big problem is that I don't think she connected with the younger voters, the ones who vote for the full 2 hours and hundreds of times. Unless Jasmine drastically steps up in her game I really think she'll go next week. If she doesn't people will end up hating her and act towards her the same way people did with John Stevens, sadly. I'm just glad Fantasia didn't go.

[David]

Unless Jasmine drastically steps up in her game I really think she'll go next week.

even if she does do well, i dont want Jasmine in the finale

[*InThisMoment*]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
even if she does do well, i dont want Jasmine in the finale I'm hoping for a Diana/Fantasia finale.

[Krisalicious]

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
I'm hoping for a Diana/Fantasia finale.

Me too!

And I love your avatar.

[David]

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Me too!

And I love your avatar. i hope Diana wins this year.

[*InThisMoment*]

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Me too!

And I love your avatar.
:D Thanks!

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
I'm hoping for a Diana/Fantasia finale. I love your avatar. Love it love it love it!

[*InThisMoment*]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I love your avatar. Love it love it love it!
Thank ya. I love yours avatar too! :D

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
Thank ya. I love yours avatar too! :D Gracias!

And it was in my In Touch Weekly (you know.. the one Clay told us not to buy bc it was SMUT hehe) and it said that John Stevens was a smitten image of Clay. O_O

Clay and Barry Manillow.. ya a lil
John and Conan.. yes

But Clay and John?!?!

[*InThisMoment*]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Gracias!

And it was in my In Touch Weekly (you know.. the one Clay told us not to buy bc it was SMUT hehe) and it said that John Stevens was a smitten image of Clay. O_O

Clay and Barry Manillow.. ya a lil
John and Conan.. yes

But Clay and John?!?!
Uhhhhhhhh. I don't really see it. :lol:

Btw, Barry Manilow has a really little chin. Just thought I'd say that. :grr:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
i hope Diana wins this year. Me too! But even if she doesnt and she comes in 2nd.. thats ok. Its good to come in 2nd sometimes. :winkgrin

[vienna waits]

On one hand, I think it's RIDICULOUS that Jasmine is still around. On the other hand, I'm ecstatic because Diana is probably going to be in the top two now. Jasmine is going to be getting lots of backlash this week. Good luck to her. Tears go a long way apparently. Are any Jas fans planning on voting for her next week? If she does make the top two, I think she'll be Justine Guarini.

[G-Force Glockstar]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
i hope Diana wins this year.

Me too! She's my 2nd favorite.
I just doubt Jasmine will win...

[G-Force Glockstar]

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
On one hand, I think it's RIDICULOUS that Jasmine is still around. On the other hand, I'm ecstatic because Diana is probably going to be in the top two now. Jasmine is going to be getting lots of backlash this week. Good luck to her. Tears go a long way apparently. Are any Jas fans planning on voting for her next week? If she does make the top two, I think she'll be Justine Guarini.

I'm a really big fan of Jasmine, but I don't know if I'll vote for her or not.

I have to admit, Diana really should win American Idol!

[Cashodeen]

It's a funny thing. How many voted this week? Usually it's in the 20 millions, so I imagine this week was like usual. You'd think Jasmine Pity Votes wouldn't make enough of a difference to keep her around... let alone keep her from the bottom two. Yet again, she's around. This week it's more blatant than ever: She does TERRIBLY... even Paula can't hide that fact, she balls her eyes out after attempting the fake smiles she is so famous for. And what happens? The girl will get at least 3rd place!

I'm stunned, stunned, stunned. That's all I can say--Stunned. I shouldn't be though. This year you've come to expect ridiculous voting outcomes like this.

[lau]

Stunned is the right word. I have been a La Toya fan since "All By Myself," which could have been the best song of the year so far. I hoped she would win. I really enjoyed the sound of her voice. Undoubtedly she was the best singer. I could actually imagine hearing a voice like hers on the radio, unlike Fantasia. Additionally, I really liked her personality even though some have criticized her for not showing enough. She has shown nothing but class and composure. She looks like a true professional on stage. She never complained, gave attitude or broke down in tears. Well, we will see what the future holds for La Toya.

Meanwhile, I don't now why I still watch this show. The voting is ridiculous. After tonight's results I almost swore off the show completely, but I'm sure I'll be tuning in next week to see Jasmine, the female John S., implode on national TV. I feel bad for Jasmine too, but next week won't be pretty.

Now, I go off to sulk "all by myself."

[David]

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
On one hand, I think it's RIDICULOUS that Jasmine is still around. On the other hand, I'm ecstatic because Diana is probably going to be in the top two now. Jasmine is going to be getting lots of backlash this week. Good luck to her. Tears go a long way apparently. Are any Jas fans planning on voting for her next week? If she does make the top two, I think she'll be Justine Guarini. Nope, im a huge fan of Jasmine but the last week i voted for her was big band week. im voting for Diana now :D

[David]

Originally posted by FullHouseFan8795
Me too! She's my 2nd favorite.
I just doubt Jasmine will win... I think it would be better for the American Idol title if Diana won

[G-Force Glockstar]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
I think it would be better for the American Idol title if Diana won

Yeah, I have a feeling that if Jasmine won, some people would get mad, and boycott her CD. She might be like John Stevens, that's what people say.

If Diana wins, it'll be great!

If Fantasia wins, it will be ok, but I might still buy her CD if she wins.

[TVFactFan]

Jasmine can't sing so i don't know would by her CD

[David]

Originally posted by TVShow Analyzer
Jasmine can't sing so i don't know would by her CD I think Jasmine can sing. She was definitley not up to par this week, but there's no doubt that she can sing. Look at her other performances. Everyone in the top 12 can sing, otherwise they wouldnt be there

[automatic princess]

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
On one hand, I think it's RIDICULOUS that Jasmine is still around. On the other hand, I'm ecstatic because Diana is probably going to be in the top two now. Jasmine is going to be getting lots of backlash this week. Good luck to her. Tears go a long way apparently. Are any Jas fans planning on voting for her next week? If she does make the top two, I think she'll be Justine Guarini.

I'm going to vote for her because I want Jasmine and Diana in the top two because I know Diana can beat Jasmine. I'm not sure Diana can beat Fantasia.

Btw, Jasmine isn't a terrible singer, she just hasn't had any really great performances lately. She needs to step it up.

[vienna waits]

Originally posted by Cyberacer
I'm going to vote for her because I want Jasmine and Diana in the top two because I know Diana can beat Jasmine. I'm not sure Diana can beat Fantasia.

Btw, Jasmine isn't a terrible singer, she just hasn't had any really great performances lately. She needs to step it up.

doing that could put Diana back in 3rd place.

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

Clay said he was pissed off after the show when LaToya got voted off. I must say, I really am becoming fond of Mr. Aiken...:D

[automatic princess]

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
doing that could put Diana back in 3rd place.

I'm also voting for Diana.

[Friendsfan#555]

I don't see why Latoya is said to have no personality. Just because her personality wasn't wild like Fantasia's doesn't mean she doesn't have one. I'm down that Jasmine still in but if people wanted to vote for her for sympathy then thats their choice but its not helping her, next week she'll be probably end up in the same situation agian not to mention people will stop liking her at all because she looks bad compared to the others.

[G-Force Glockstar]

Originally posted by Cyberacer
I'm also voting for Diana.

Me too! I really want both Diana AND Jasmine in the final 2.
I really like Fantasia, though.

But next Tuesday who should I vote for more? Jasmine or Diana?

[David]

Originally posted by FullHouseFan8795
Me too! I really want both Diana AND Jasmine in the final 2.
I really like Fantasia, though.

But next Tuesday who should I vote for more? Jasmine or Diana? I think you should support Diana. I think it'll be better to see Diana in the finale with Fantasia (im assuming that all of Latoyas votes will go to Fantasia), rather than Jasmine and Fatnasia, and seeing Jasmine literally get beaten down