So far, who do you miss the most on American Idol?

[G-Force Glockstar]

They did a poll like this a while ago on idolsonfox.com

And I wanna do one here. It was a few weeks ago when they did it on idolsonfox.

Out of 8 contestents that got elimanated, who do you miss the most?
Please vote in my poll!

Thank you!

[G-Force Glockstar]

And this poll will only last for 30 days. I set that up because American Idol will be done in a little less than a month.
So hopefully that wasn't a stupid idea....

But I miss most of the American Idol contestants alot.
So it's kinda hard to decide who I miss the most. When Jon Peter Lewis got out, I started getting really sad because then some more of my favorites (including JPL) were getting out.

[David]

i voted for .. Leah, Amy, JPL, George. But i miss George the most. Im thankful that none of my big favorites havent gotten eliminated yet. My 5 favorites made the top 5, so from here on out, every elimination is gonna be sad.

Heres how i felt in each elimination

Leah- she deserved it, but for some reason i felt sad for her, because America never really did anything for her. The only reason she was in the top 12 is because Paula... and i think that if she had picked a better song, she wouldve done a tad bit better

Matt- i didnt really mind. he was a good performer, and an early favorite of mine. i actually sort of forgot about him :lol:

Amy- i was sad when she was out, because she's such a bright light, and shes funny.

Camile- i felt that it was to her benefit that she should leave, because she was so scared every week! i thought it was sad, but i dont miss her that much

JPL- i didnt expect it, and i realized that i sorta took his presence for granted. i mean i was never crazy about him, but he was my 6th fave, and at one point, one of my top 5. when he left, i was sad, because he was a blast to watch.

Jennifer- i was actually happy she left, because that "three diva" thing was getting annoying, and she oversang a lot........ and yeah. she was good, but i was never an intense fan

John- i didnt really like him, but ive got to give him his props for surviving through all that crap put against him. people are way too serious

George- i mean, yeah i am sad that he left, but he did make the top 5, and thats awesome, everyone has to leave at one point, except for the winner.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I voted JPL. I really miss him. I also miss Stevens because he made me laugh each week :lol:. He was entertaing. Anyone see him on Conan? Good TV!

[*InThisMoment*]

John S. *sniffle* :(

[Brian]

I never liked Leah Labelle. One of these days I'm going to write to Paula Abdul and ask why she chose her.

I really liked Matt. Decent voice. He's not Top 5 material but he's better than Leah, Camile, John, and maybe JPL.

Amy was voted off too soon. I think it is one of the biggest shockers of the season in my opinion. It goes to show what can happen when too many fans assume safety.

Camile was terrible. I didn't like her in Group 2 in the semifinals and I was surprised that she lasted as long as she did.

JPL's departure was another big shocker. But there was no way he could have been in the Top 5 this year.

Jennifer was great. I think Ryan did the right thing telling fans on the day she was voted off that they should vote on talent and that it isn't a popularity contest.

I cannot understand what was so great about John Stevens. He's unique but in a negative light to me. I think after Jennifer Hudson's elimination, the fans heeded Ryan's advice and voted on talent.

It is unfortunate that George has left us but the past few weeks he was mediocre. He jumped the shark after Movie night and never got back on track. But I did like him in Big Band night.

[Brian]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I voted JPL. I really miss him. I also miss Stevens because he made me laugh each week :lol:. He was entertaing. Anyone see him on Conan? Good TV!


I saw him on Letterman. :lol:

[-*Forever*-]

Amy. Of course.

:D

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by Brian
I saw him on Letterman. :lol: Grr. I missed that. :cuss:

[Krisalicious]

JPL, of course. I miss Amy the second most.

[david&maddie4ever]

Matt Metzger. :D

[vienna waits]

Suzy Vulaca! After that, I'd have to say Amy Adams. She was my pick to win it all during the Hollywood auditions (remember her acapella Power of Love.. it was awesome). I voted for her for two hours in the top 32 round, but I didn't like her as much once she got to the top 12. She still left way too early.

[G-Force Glockstar]

Originally posted by Brian
I saw him on Letterman. :lol:

You did?! I wonder how many shows I'm missing that has JPL on it now....
I wish they're was a schdule (I can't spell it).

[G-Force Glockstar]

Here are my thoughts on the elminations.

I can't say Leah's or Matt's because I never heard them, but I did once in an audio clip. They sounded ok.

I think Amy was GREAT and it was just my first time I heard her (when she sang on March 30). I was sad when she left.

I think Camielle was good, but not very many people liked her. Bu t I thought she was good, but I knew she probably wouldn't fit in with the final four now.

I think JPL was defintly a complete shock when he got elminated. He was 100 percent talented. He sings perfect, he dances really cool, and he is a really nice role model!

I think it was sad when Jennifer got out. That was another shock to everyone. Jennifer was awesome!

I think John Stevens was a very nice boy, who always tried his best even with pressure. He sang very beautifully on "Music of my heart". It was kinda sad to see him go...

I think George was good, and now the competition will seem funny without any boys. George was always active and never shy like Diana. George was a good singer, and he seemed very nice.

[I am Him]

Amy left sooner than she should have

[-*Leah*-]

Jon Peter Lewis, of course.

[~*Hannah_Lee*~]

I miss Jon the most. John S. second most.

I really didnt care to much for Leah and Matt's leaving. Amy was really sad to watch go, but I kind of expected it. Camille, I was glad to see her go then...but now I kind of appreciate her more. Jon Peter was of course the biggest shock. Jennifer was another shock, but she wasn't one of my favorites. John S. was another favorite, and I hated to see him go, but he looked so relieved. It wasn't as upsetting to me as JPL. George...I didn't really like him either, so I didn't really get upset about him either.

[G-Force Glockstar]

I think most of the elimatations were kinda shocking, but JPL's elimanation (when he left) was the most shocking!
I still miss him, and I can't help thinking about him every single day still.