Favorite AI season?

[~Tropical Punch 19~]

I would probably have to go with season 2. I didn't really watch season 1, execpt for a few parts of it and the last episode. Season 3 has been good, and hasn't been quite as predictable as season 2, but I think you could connect more with the season 2 people.

[Krisalicious]

1. Season 3
2. Season 2
3. Season 1

[tinytin3]

Season 3 by far. The talent is just so much better, and its so unpredictable, which makes it more interesting. I've been to a message board where they talked about this before, and when the people say they hate season 3, the reason is "There's no Clay". Clay cant be on every single season!! I like Clay, but i mean.. hes successful now, move onl.

[vienna waits]

season 2. I had three favorites then. This season I have one and I enjoy one other. I like downloading and listening to season one mp3s though just because of the nostagia and old schoolness that they have.

[ChristyHeadIsSexy]

So far I like season 2 the best. What do you guys mean when you say season 3 is unpredictable. They are choosing mostly the same themes from last season. I thought season 2 was a little bit more unpredictable at times, like how they did the wild card show.

[Brian]

The two seasons I have seen, 2 and 3, are good in their own ways. Season 2 had only a few really good singers (Clay, Ruben, Kim Locke, Rickey Smith, Kim Caldwell) while Season 3 had only 4 singers that were subpar (John Stevens, JPL, Camile, Leah) while the rest were great. But the few good singers in AI2's Top 12 were phenomenal, AI3's great singers are just great singers.

[~*Hannah_Lee*~]

I definately like Season 3 the best, so far. I mean, I haven't liked a contestant as much as I liked Jon Peter Lewis. Even with him gone, though, I still think it's been the best season...lots of good talent, but varied talent.

[-*Leah*-]

Season 3. Last years was good though, Kim Caldwell, and Kim Locke were both great, and Clay is too. The first season had Kelly and Nikki though. Ahh well...JPL still beats all of them in my book.

[David]

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
So far I like season 2 the best. What do you guys mean when you say season 3 is unpredictable. They are choosing mostly the same themes from last season. I thought season 2 was a little bit more unpredictable at times, like how they did the wild card show. I think its unpredictable because of the voting. Everytime someone makes a bottom 3 prediction, it always ends up wrong, and theres always a shocker every week in the results

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Season 2, hands down. I've been watching and taping season 3 religiously, but nothing beats last season. I agree with ~Tropical Punch 19~, where you could connect more with last years contestants. They seemed to show more personality than this years. Only ones who stood out this year with personality were JPL, Amy, and Matt.. all that are now gone.