American Idol: Same Song, Different Contestant

[Krisalicious]

During the three seasons of American Idol, people from different seasons or sometimes even the same season have performed the same song, so I'm going to start off with a few and just post which you think was better, and feel free to post some of your own too.

Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/ George Huff (AI3)

My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/ Diana DeGarmo (AI3)

To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/ Clay Aiken (AI2)

Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2) / Jennifer Hudson (AI3)

[Krisalicious]

Oh yeah btw, out of the ones I just posted, this is who I prefer for each:

Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard

My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke

To Love Somebody- Clay Aiken

Heatwave- Jennifer Hudson

[vienna waits]

EVERY song that Jasmine has sang this season has been sung on AI before.. this week will be the first when she isn't doing something from a former Idol.

Jasmine Songs...

Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) [didnt hear angela's]
Inseparabe - Kim Locke (season 2) [prefer KLo while it was Jas at her best]
Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) [both bad!]
You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) [kelly]
Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) [clay, of cource]
When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) [didn't hear Jim's but she couldn't have been worse than him]

some others...

I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia [KLo]
Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya [La Toya!]
Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson [Kim C... my ears are still getting over Lisa's horredous version]
Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams [Amy]
I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. [Trenyce]
Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff [George]

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

MY PREFERENCES:




Jasmine songs:
Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) [didnt hear angela's]
Inseparabe - [b]Kim Locke (season 2)
Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) [both bad!]
You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1)
Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2)
When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) Jasmine
=
I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia
Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya
Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson
Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams
I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H.
Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff
Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/George Huff (AI3)
My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Diana DeGarmo (AI3)
To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/Clay Aiken (AI2) Theres like.. no comparison on that one.
Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Jennifer Hudson (AI3)

[vienna waits]

a trillion more i came up with last night:

Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman [Tamyra]
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke [haven't heard Kelly's.. id say theyre equally great]
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay [Clay]
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben [Josh]
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott [Clay]
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille [Justin (one of the rare times i like him)]
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille [Jeffrey]
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille [Julia]
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away [Corey Clark]
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens [RJ]
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia [Fantasia]
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah [TRENYCE]
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah [Vanessa]

okidokie thats all for now.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray (though I dont know the song -.-/Ashley Hartman
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away.. Jeff.. who was the other one??! :rotflmao: No wait.. JPL -.- So yes.. JPL
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leahp

[Krisalicious]

Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman [Tamyra]
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke [haven't heard either]
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay [CLAY]
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben [Ruben]
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott [Clay]
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille [ehh...I was actually listening to Justin's earlier on my old season 1 American Idol greatest moments CD and he sings that song, but I don't really like it so..Camile]
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille [Camile]
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille [I haven't heard Julias, but Camile's was pretty bad...]
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away [...JPL:p ]
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens [RJ. John's was really, really boring]
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia [I like both]
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah [Trenyce]
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah [Vanessa]

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

One Voice: Kelly, Clay & Ruben OR Diana DeGarmo

Turn The Beat Around: Carmen Rasmusen OR Diana DeGarmo

Im going with Kelly, Clay and Ruben, and then Diana for TTBA.

[David]

Jasmines performances
Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) JASMINE
Inseparabe - [b]Kim Locke (season 2) JASMINE
Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) JULIA
You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) KELLY
Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) CLAY
When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) JASMINE
=
I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia KIM
Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya LATOYA
Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson KIM
Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams TRENYCE
I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. TRENYCE
Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff GEORGE
Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/George Huff (AI3) GEORGE
My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Diana DeGarmo (AI3) KIMBERLEY
To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/Clay Aiken (AI2) CLAY
Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Jennifer Hudson (AI3) THE GROUP SONG lol
Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman TAMYRA
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke KELLY
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay CLAY
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben RUBEN
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott CLAY
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille JUSTIN
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille CAMILE
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille JULIA
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away COREY
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens RJ
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia FANTASIA
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah TRENYCE
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah LEAH

[David]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
One Voice: Kelly, Clay & Ruben OR Diana DeGarmo

Turn The Beat Around: Carmen Rasmusen OR Diana DeGarmo

Im going with Kelly, Clay and Ruben, and then Diana for TTBA.

One Voice- Kelly (but Dianas was almost as good)

Turn the Beat Around- Diana DeGarmo!!!